Unlocking AI's Potential in the Arts: A Call for Collaboration & Pragmatic Leadership
.webp)
The path of rejecting new technologies outright and blindly lashing out against every potential risk rarely ends well. Luddites have been repeatedly routed by the inexorable march of progress throughout history. A far better approach is to proactively investigate how to extract maximum benefit from powerful new tools while mitigating potential downsides through collaboration, especially in proven existing organizations models like unions.
As generative AI massively disrupts creative fields, clinging to the status quo is no longer tenable. Doubling down on legacy models and traditions will only cede ground to companies barreling ahead with these transformative capabilities. For artists and their advocates, the wiser strategy is to lean into this technological revolution from a position of pragmatic leadership.
Share Frontier Foundry Substack
Over 200 prominent musicians have signed an open letter demanding protections against AI mimicking their voices, likenesses, and music without consent. Issued by the Artist Rights Alliance advocacy group, the letter calls on tech companies to pledge not to undermine human artists with AI tools that could enable the unauthorized commercial exploitation of creators' identities. While stopping short of banning AI use in music entirely, the artists argue this "predatory" misuse of their work must cease to protect human creativity and fairly compensate creators through royalties.
The artists' unified call for legal protections and ethical guidelines around generative AI's impact on their profession follows on the heels of last year's SAG-AFTRA strike, where AI was a significant point of contention. Rather than simply engaging in a defensive posture, however, moments like this present crucial opportunities for artists, unions, and policymakers to proactively shape how these technologies can empower rather than replace human creators.
Imagine if creative unions took the bold step of officially recognizing and sanctioning AI technologies - not as an unavoidable threat, but as a new category of workers and partners that could expand unions' scope and revenues. Unions could require any AI system operating in their industry to formally register as a union member and be bound by a code of ethics, including revenue sharing.
Under such a forward-looking model, the unions would gain insights into AI companies' practices through mandated transparency around their systems' development, training data and commercial deployments. AI providers would pay dues, a portion of which could be directed to revenue-sharing pools that compensate human creators when their works are utilized in training datasets or become displaced by AI systems.
As the policy landscape evolves with lawmakers looking to establish guardrails around generative AI, embracing these technologies could afford unions greater influence. They could help drive regulations protecting members' rights while still allowing responsible development benefiting their industries.
Critics would likely raise reasonable concerns around an AI system's ability to collectively bargain or advocate for workplace conditions. And the ethical implications of granting artificial systems explicit protections intended for human laborers deserve scrutiny.
However, taking an open-minded stance and bringing AI developers, ethicists and artists together could spark innovative proposals accommodating all stakeholders' interests. Perhaps tiers of union membership corresponding to different classes of AI could be established. Or a separate-but-allied institution representing AIs' unique considerations could be formed.
By working with pioneers in the AI field and forward-thinking policymakers, entertainment unions could shape a responsible framework that respects creators' rights while harnessing the incredible leveraged labor and lucrative opportunities generative AI undoubtedly offers. Those embracing this approach would secure both their members' and their own relevance in our rapidly changing world.